Advocates seek protection for Mel’s Drive-In, the city’s last remaining Googie-style building, as developers allegedly plan an eight-story apartment complex.

    By Zach Armstrong

    One of Santa Monica’s historic eateries could be torn down for a new high-rise. But local preservationists are aiming to defend it the best way they know how: with a historic designation.

    Mel’s Drive-In, which occupies the former Penguin Coffee Shop site while preserving its Googie architecture, is facing redevelopment. The owner of the property plans to sell the 67-year-old restaurant to developers to make way for an 8-story apartment building with 138 units. Plans also call for 5,667 sq ft of ground-floor commercial space and a semi-underground parking garage. Mel’s lease to the property ends in 2029, according to an employee. 

    News of the potential redevelopment, made public by the conservancy’s social media page, has already drawn backlash. One customer commented, “Santa Monica will have no type of character anymore soon.” An employee at the diner said that he was unaware of the potential redevelopment until he walked into work on Thursday morning.

    Now, local advocates are racing to protect that building. The Santa Monica Conservancy and Los Angeles Conservancy jointly sent an application to the Landmarks Commission to grant the building with a historic landmark status, a move that would shield it from being dismantled.

    “When you preserve buildings, what you’re doing is you are creating a visual archive of places that tell stories,” said Nina Fresco, Vice President of the Santa Monica Conservancy. “Having these cultural resources can be used to understand what’s happening now. If they look at this architecture that was responding to automobiles and car culture, then you look at what they’re building now, you start to understand things about yourself and today.”

    The landmarks commission will hold a public hearing on the landmark application on Dec. 14. 

    Representatives from Mel’s did not immediately respond to inquiry.

    Built in 1959, the Penguin Coffee Shop served Santa Monica from the corner of Olympic and Lincoln Boulevards for decades. After the diner’s closure in 1991, the site operated as a dentist’s office for the next quarter-century before Mel’s Drive-in signed a long-term lease for the property. A penguin statue is still perched on top of Mel’s signage in the front, paying homage to the building’s original operator.

    The former Penguin Coffee Shop site stands as Santa Monica’s last example of the famous ‘Googie’ style. The architectural aesthetic, created by architects Armet & Davis, often features a sharply angled exterior with plate glass walls, an over-scaled roof and an illuminated interior. The design became prominent for Southern California diners and restaurants in the 1950s and 1960s, the era of freeways and road trips. The eye-catching elements were meant to attract passing motorists.

    Mel’s wouldn’t become the only ‘Googie’ coffee shop in Los Angeles saved by landmark status and community pressure. Johnie’s Coffee Shop, featured in the films The Big Lebowski and American History X, was designated as a Historic-Cultural Monument in 2013 after plans for a Metro station at Wilshire and Fairfax sparked fears of demolition. The historic NORMS Restaurant in West Hollywood was slated to become a Raising Cane’s until local outcry made the chicken strip chain reverse course. 

    But not all of Armet & Davis’ Los Angeles creations have been as lucky. In 2016, the former Tiny Naylor’s restaurant in Beverly Hills was cleared for a Metro storage equipment site during the Purple Line’s construction.

    The landmark designation wouldn’t prevent all and any development at the site. Rather, developers would have to build around the structural elements that give the building its historic nature, as happened with the historic Rapp Saloon on 2nd Street, according to Fresno. 

    Replacing Mel’s Drive In with a high-rise would be one of the last steps to turn Lincoln’s 1600 block into a continuous stretch of such developments. Besides Mel’s, the Lincoln Car Wash & Detail and a vacant commercial space at 1600 Lincoln Blvd. stand as the only non-high-rise structures on the block.

    Share.

    Comments are closed.